Skip to main content
Headway
Headshot of Michelle Kagel, LMFT

Michelle Kagel

Therapist(she/her)
11 years of experience
  • Virtual & in-person
  • Anxiety, Stress management, Maternal mental health, Relationship issues, Women's issues
  • Family therapy, Individual therapy

Great to meet you!

Let’s be real, nobody calls a therapist when life is going swimmingly. You’re here because something feels off, stuck, or like a record that keeps skipping to the same awful part. Recognizing you need support? That’s the hardest part, and you’ve already done it.

Hi, I'm Michelle. I'm a therapist who specializes in relationship stress, people-pleasing, and the anxiety that comes with trying to hold it all together. I work particularly well with people who are either overly analytical and "don't do feelings," or who are feeling all the feelings but don't know what all to do with them.

My background is unusual—I started in entertainment, moved into education, and eventually earned master's degree from Thomas Jefferson University in Marriage and Family Therapy in 2015. Throughout my varied career, I keep meeting smart, ambitious people who were great at solving everyone else's problems but struggled with their own and all of the answers they found felt impossible. If that sounds familiar, you're exactly who I love working with.

I see patterns in relationships the way profilers solve mysteries in Criminal Minds. I'm curious, direct, and collaborative—not here to judge or hand out cookie-cutter advice. Instead, I'll help you figure out what you actually want, why certain patterns keep showing up, and how to make changes that stick.

My approach to therapy

My style is warm but with a little edge. I'll make jokes, quote movies, and occasionally swear, because therapy works best when you can come up as your most authentic self. I do well with clients navigating morally gray or complicated areas of life—the messy stuff where there are no easy answers.

Depending on your needs, we might use Emotionally Focused Therapy, Internal Family Systems, or Master Conflict Theory, but we'll always go with what feels right for you. And here's the thing: there isn't a kind of therapy I do with my clients that I haven't also experienced myself. I think it's only ethical to have walked the walk if we're going to talk the talk.

What you can expect from me

Nobody's in the best place when they're meeting a new therapist, so my goal is to set you at ease. We'll talk about what brought you here (virtually or in person), what has and hasn't worked so far, and what you're hoping from our work together. I'll ask questions to make sure I understand what you're after, then share some possible treatment options. You'll have the chance to ask me anything you'd like—I believe the more you know, the better therapy will go. I always offer a free initial consult phone consultation so all it will cost you is your time.

About me

  • I identify as
    Caucasian, Cisgender Woman
  • My style is
    Humorous, Challenging, Warm

Qualification and insurance

  • Years of experience
    11 years of experience
  • Training
    Masters in Marriage and Family Therapy at Jefferson Medical College of Thomas Jefferson University, BA (Bachelor of Arts) at The George Washington University
  • License type
    LMFT (Licensed Marriage/Family Therapist) (Pennsylvania)
  • Licensed in
  • Insurance accepted
    Aetna, Capital Blue Cross Pennsylvania, Carelon Behavioral Health, Cigna, Curative, Geisinger, Geisinger Medicare Advantage, Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield Pennsylvania, Horizon Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Jersey, Independence Blue Cross Pennsylvania - Virtual National Network, Independence Medicare Advantage, Oscar, Oxford, Providence Health Plan, The Health Plan, United Healthcare, United Healthcare Medicare Advantage

Cost

Care details

  • Top specialties
    Anxiety, Stress management, Maternal mental health, Relationship issues, Women's issues
  • More specialties
  • Therapy methods
    Psychoeducational Family Therapy, Emotion Focused Therapy (EFT), Humanistic, Cognitive Behavioral (CBT), Psychodynamic, Strength-Based
  • Care types
    Family therapy, Individual therapy
  • Ages served
    Seniors, Adults
  • Languages
    English
  • Location
    50 West Welsh Pool Road
    Exton, PA 19341