Skip to main content
Headway
Headshot of Tony Talley, LMHC

Tony Talley

Therapist
14 years of experience
58 patients on Headway
  • Virtual & in-person
  • Anxiety, Family issues
  • Individual therapy, Family therapy

Great to meet you!

My practice primarily focuses on individual counseling for adults ages 22 and older.


My style is relaxed, warm, honest, direct, and sometimes unconventional. I believe good therapy begins with a strong therapeutic relationship. Before jumping into techniques or trying to fix something, I want to understand who you are, what you've experienced, and what brings you to counseling.

I frequently work with individuals navigating anxiety, relationship difficulties, betrayal, self-worth, people-pleasing, major life transitions, and patterns that keep repeating despite wanting something different.

I appreciate working with people who are willing to be curious about themselves, even when that process becomes uncomfortable.

Therapy with me is collaborative and active. I'll bring experience, questions, observations, and practical feedback. I won't simply sit back and nod, but I also won't tell you how to live your life.

I maintain my independent practice, Finding Your Peace Counseling, while working with Headway to provide insurance-covered individual therapy.

Finding the right therapeutic fit matters to me. I'd rather help you find the right therapist than force a relationship that isn't working.

My approach to therapy

Counseling that's supportive, direct, and real.


I believe lasting change begins with understanding yourself, not simply learning techniques to manage symptoms.

My approach is relationship-based, integrative, and individualized. I draw from attachment-based, family systems, emotionally focused, and other evidence-informed perspectives depending on your needs.

I'm interested in understanding the patterns underneath what's happening in your life, including how you think, respond emotionally, relate to others, and make decisions.

I may ask difficult questions, point out patterns, or challenge you to consider a different perspective. But that directness always comes from a place of respect and curiosity.

My goal isn't to fix you. It's to help you better understand yourself so you can make more intentional choices in your relationships, your reactions, and your life.

What you can expect from me

Our first session is primarily about getting to know each other.

I want to hear what's bringing you to counseling, what you've already tried, what you're hoping will change, and what you need from a therapist.

We'll discuss relevant background information, your concerns, and what working together might look like.

My style is conversational, relaxed, honest, and direct. I use humor when appropriate, ask questions, and offer observations. I won't rush to challenge you before we've established enough trust to do meaningful work.

The first few sessions also give us an opportunity to determine whether we're a good therapeutic fit.

You should feel comfortable evaluating me, too. Therapy is a relationship, and both of us should have confidence that the work we're doing is worthwhile.

About me

  • I identify as
    Black or African descent, Caucasian, Cisgender Man
  • My style is
    Challenging, Affirming, Empowering

Qualification and insurance

  • Years of experience
    14 years of experience
  • Training
    MA (Master of Arts) at Indiana Wesleyan University
  • License type
    LMHC (Licensed Mental Health Counselor) (Indiana)
  • Licensed in
  • Insurance accepted
    Aetna, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, Carelon Behavioral Health, Cigna, Oscar, Oxford, Providence Health Plan, United Healthcare

Cost

Care details

  • Top specialties
    Anxiety, Family issues
  • More specialties
    Substance use / addiction, Depression, Stress management, Grief or loss, Relationship issues, Women's issues, Identity issues, Trauma
  • Therapy methods
    Emotion Focused Therapy (EFT), Seeking Safety, Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT), Attachment Based Family Therapy, Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT), Attachment Based, Bowen Family Systems, Interpersonal Psychotherapy (IPT), Relational, Cognitive Processing (CPT), Internal Family Systems Therapy (IFS), Motivational Interviewing, Solution Focused Brief Therapy (SFBT)
  • Care types
    Individual therapy, Family therapy
  • Ages served
    Adults
  • Languages
    English
  • Location
    14074 Trade Center Drive Suite 136
    Fishers, IN 46038

Nearby areas