Skip to main content
Headway
Headshot of Tony Talley, LMHC

Tony Talley

Therapist
14 years of experience
  • Virtual & in-person
  • Anxiety, Family issues
  • Individual therapy, Family therapy

Great to meet you!

I work with adults age 22 and older who are ready to better understand themselves, their relationships, and the patterns that may be keeping them stuck.

My style is relaxed, warm, direct, and sometimes unconventional. I believe good therapy starts with a strong therapeutic relationship, so I take time to get to know you before jumping into interventions or trying to “fix” something. Once we have built that foundation, we begin the work together.

I often work with adults navigating relationship difficulties, betrayal, anxiety, self-worth, people-pleasing, major life transitions, and patterns that continue to repeat despite wanting something different. I especially enjoy working with people who are willing to be curious about themselves, even when what we discover may be uncomfortable.

My office may be the physical space, but the counseling session belongs to you. I will bring clinical experience, questions, observations, honesty, and practical feedback, but I expect you to bring the concerns you want help understanding, solving, or approaching differently. Therapy with me is collaborative and active. I won't simply sit back and nod, but I also won't tell you how to live your life.

I contract with Headway to provide insurance-covered individual therapy while also maintaining my own private practice. Because of that, finding the right therapeutic fit is important to me. I would rather help you find the right therapist than try to force a therapeutic relationship that doesn't fit.

My approach to therapy

I believe lasting change begins with understanding—not simply reducing symptoms. Before we focus heavily on techniques or interventions, I want to understand you: how you think, how you relate to others, what you have experienced, what you have already tried, and what you hope will be different.

My work is relationship-based and integrative. Depending on your needs, I may draw from Attachment-Based Therapy, Bowen Family Systems Theory, Emotionally Focused Therapy, Object Relations Theory, Mentalization-Based concepts, Polyvagal-informed interventions, and trauma-informed principles.

You don't need to know what all of those terms mean. That's my job.

What matters is that we use what is clinically useful to understand the patterns underneath what is happening in your life. I may ask questions that challenge you, point out patterns I notice, or ask you to consider something from a different perspective. That directness will always come from a place of respect and curiosity.

My hope is not that you leave therapy feeling “fixed.” My hope is that you understand yourself well enough to make more intentional choices in your relationships, your reactions, and your life.

What you can expect from me

Our first session is primarily about getting to know each other.

I want to hear what is happening in your own words rather than simply work my way through a checklist. We will talk about what brought you to therapy, what you have already tried, what you would like to be different, and how I may be able to help.

I may ask questions such as:

• Why therapy now? • If therapy were successful, what would be different in your life? • What have you tried already? • What patterns do you notice yourself repeating? • What do you need from a therapist for this relationship to be useful?

You should also be evaluating me. Therapy is a relationship, and clinical experience alone does not guarantee that two people will work well together.

My style is conversational, relaxed, warm, honest, and direct. I may use humor. I may challenge something you say. I may notice a pattern and ask you to look at it differently. But I don't believe meaningful work should begin before we've developed enough trust to do it well.

Usually, the first few sessions help us determine whether the relationship feels productive and whether my approach matches what you need. If we decide we're a good fit, we continue the work. If either of us believes someone else could serve you better, I am comfortable having that conversation and helping with referrals.

About me

  • I identify as
    Black or African descent, Caucasian, Cisgender Man
  • My style is
    Challenging, Affirming, Empowering

Qualification and insurance

  • Years of experience
    14 years of experience
  • Training
    MA (Master of Arts) at Indiana Wesleyan University
  • License type
    LMHC (Licensed Mental Health Counselor) (Indiana)
  • Licensed in
  • Insurance accepted
    Aetna, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Carelon Behavioral Health, Horizon Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Jersey, Oscar, Oxford, Providence Health Plan, United Healthcare

Cost

Care details

  • Top specialties
    Anxiety, Family issues
  • More specialties
    Substance use / addiction, Depression, Stress management, Grief or loss, Relationship issues, Women's issues, Identity issues, Trauma
  • Therapy methods
    Emotion Focused Therapy (EFT), Seeking Safety, Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT), Attachment Based Family Therapy, Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT), Attachment Based, Bowen Family Systems, Interpersonal Psychotherapy (IPT), Relational, Cognitive Processing (CPT), Internal Family Systems Therapy (IFS), Motivational Interviewing, Solution Focused Brief Therapy (SFBT)
  • Care types
    Individual therapy, Family therapy
  • Ages served
    Adults
  • Languages
    English
  • Location
    14074 Trade Center Drive Suite 136
    Fishers, IN 46038

Nearby areas