Skip to main content
Headway

Find a therapist in Fishers, IN — covered by insurance

Therapist and patient in a therapy session
Calculator Illustration
Get a cost estimate
People with insurance pay as low as $0 per session through Headway

Top therapists in Fishers, IN accepting new patients

Seeking mental health support in Fishers? Headway connects you with 829 warm, solution-oriented providers across Nickel Plate District, Geist, and surrounding neighborhoods. Many sessions covered by insurance with patients saving an average of 75%, and providers often offer free consultations.

Jessica Gaffney

Jessica Gaffney

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


Reach me directly at [email protected] to schedule a consult or appt.

I also accept Medicare, AmBetter, UMR and United plans.

https://care.tavahealth.com/providers/jessica-gaffney

Therapy is a healing of the past, UNFOLDING OF THE PRESENT AND gift for your future. You will see growth from day one.

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, OCD, PTSD, Relationship issues
Creative, Participatory, Solution-oriented
Accepts 4 insurance carriers
Erin Moore

Erin Moore

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My role is to gently challenge you and encourage new ways of thinking that promote growth, healing, and well-being.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, End of life care
Creative, Humorous, Open-minded
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
Alexandrea DeFelice

Alexandrea DeFelice

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My therapeutic style is warm and active. I want you to feel supported, comfortable, and appropriately challenged in order for you to make meaningful changes in your life.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Identity issues
Empowering, Humorous, Open-minded
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
Hollie Shigley

Hollie Shigley

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I believe that healing isn't about becoming someone new, it's about reconnecting with who you are underneath the stress, expectations, and challenges you've been carrying.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Maternal mental health
Creative, Inquisitive, Solution-oriented
Accepts 7 insurance carriers
Kamryn VanWanzeele

Kamryn VanWanzeele

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“Less anxiety, feeling focused, and seeing the end in sight — this is how you'll feel after every session.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, End of life care
Affirming, Creative, Energetic
Accepts 10 insurance carriers
Heather Rozack

Heather Rozack

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My goal is for you to leave the first session feeling seen, grounded, and like you finally have someone in your corner.”
Anxiety, Depression, End of life care, Grief or loss, Infertility
Empowering, Inquisitive, Warm
Accepts 6 insurance carriers
Lori Karman

Lori Karman

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I am passionate about helping clients recognize their strengths and use them to navigate life's challenges.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues
Empowering, Holistic, Solution-oriented
Accepts 5 insurance carriers
Shira Belkov

Shira Belkov

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I work from a strengths based approach and help clients cultivate self-awareness to make positive changes.”
Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss, Maternal mental health
Affirming, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 4 insurance carriers
Patricia Adeleye

Patricia Adeleye

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Indiana


“I place strong emphasis on patient education, shared decision-making, and ongoing assessment to ensure that care remains both effective and responsive to each person's evolving circumstances and goals.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Grief or loss
Holistic, Open-minded, Solution-oriented
Accepts 9 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Lindsay Wolff

Lindsay Wolff

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


As a Licensed Clinical Social Worker, I believe that prioritizing mental health is an integral part of quality of life. Congratulations on taking the first step towards self improvement! I have been practicing for 20 years with a focus on individuals experiencing depression, anxiety, ADHD, and difficulty with life transitions. I am also passionate about working with couples who are experiencing disconnection, conflict, and communication issues.

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Family issues
Inquisitive, Participatory, Warm
Accepts 7 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Derek Blagojevic

Derek Blagojevic

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“Skill building from DBT therapy addresses emotional regulation, CBT reframes negative thoughts, and Solution-Focused Therapy leverages strengths and sets goals, while mindfulness cultivates present-moment awareness for overall emotional well-being.”
Anxiety, Depression, Identity issues, LGBTQIA+, OCD
Affirming, Open-minded, Solution-oriented
Accepts 10 insurance carriers
Sarah Benitez-Zandi

Sarah Benitez-Zandi

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“Rather than staying only at the level of insight, we work at the level where trauma is stored, the body and nervous system.”
Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, End of life care, Family issues
Challenging, Humorous, Open-minded
Jennifer Weir-Harden

Jennifer Weir-Harden

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I do not have a cookie cutter approach to therapy. I use a trauma-informed, relational approach grounded in psychodynamic and attachment-based therapy.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss
Holistic, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 1 insurance carrier
Shaunita Montout

Shaunita Montout

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I believe that every life experience shapes who we are, yet moments of misalignment between how we see ourselves and whom we aspire to be are natural—and deeply human.”
Anxiety, Depression, Grief or loss, Maternal mental health, Men's issues
Holistic, Participatory, Solution-oriented
Accepts 3 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Tara Degunya

Tara Degunya

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • Fort Wayne, IN


“I am a Certified Clinical Trauma Professional. By using Cognitive Processing Therapy and Exposure Therapy, I treat Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.”
Anxiety, Depression, Grief or loss, PTSD, Stress management
Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm
Accepts 10 insurance carriers
Christina Bame

Christina Bame

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I provide a safe, affirming space for folks experiencing trauma, bipolar, psychosis, depression, identity exploration, and spiritual awakening.”
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Identity issues
Direct, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 10 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Adrianna Crouch

Adrianna Crouch

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My style is direct and collaborative while infusing humor to ease the heaviness that can arise in everyday life.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions
Challenging, Direct, Empowering
Accepts 2 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Deacon Farrelly

Deacon Farrelly

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


Hello and congratulations for taking the first and sometimes hardest step of looking for a therapist. I’m a Licensed Clinical Social Worker in the states of IN, KY LA, MO, NV, TX, WA and WV. I have the great privilege of working with adolescents and adults seeking assistance in improving their overall mental health and associated challenges. I’ve been in the behavioral health arena for over 40 years and have held numerous direct care and clinical leadership roles in a variety of settings. My joy comes from helping people navigate life's challenges.

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions, Depression
Humorous, Participatory, Warm
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
Michael Ross

Michael Ross

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I have special experience with high-achieving professionals, first responders, military personnel, and individuals navigating high-stress environments.”
Anxiety, Family issues, Identity issues, LGBTQIA+, Men's issues
Creative, Open-minded, Participatory
Accepts 11 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Elwin Trammell

Elwin Trammell

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I am trauma- and PTSD-informed, and I have extensive training in treating trauma. My approach to therapy is holistic...”
Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss
Empowering, Humorous, Solution-oriented
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
Dr. Michael Whiteside

Dr. Michael Whiteside

Therapist

Virtual • Bloomington, IN


“I am a compassionate, communal, and comedic Licensed Clinical Social Worker dedicated to helping others regain control of their life and living life to the fullest.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues
Affirming, Empowering, Warm
Accepts 5 insurance carriers
Roxana Kennedy

Roxana Kennedy

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My style is collaborative and compassionate, and I'll honor your unique story as we work together to explore new perspectives.”
Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Grief or loss, PTSD
Empowering, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 10 insurance carriers
Chioma Nwokoro

Chioma Nwokoro

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Indiana


“She has decades of extensive experience and expertise in psychiatric nursing working with the underserved, underprivileged, and vulnerable populations.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Grief or loss
Empowering, Holistic, Open-minded
Accepts 7 insurance carriers
Laurel Bourgeois

Laurel Bourgeois

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I want to meet you where you are at in your journey to wellbeing and both gently support and challenge you to be your very best self.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, End of life care
Empowering, Energetic, Warm
Accepts 8 insurance carriers
Dr. Marvelyn Thompson

Dr. Marvelyn Thompson

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Mishawaka, IN


“I aim to use Talk therapy, Christian Counseling, Medication Therapy, and Natural Remedies to help people navigate through the dark and challenging path of depression, anxiety, and other mental illnesses so that they can experience the fullness of...”
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Eating disorders, Panic disorders
Empowering, Humorous, Open-minded
Accepts 7 insurance carriers
Olivia Hartman

Olivia Hartman

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I combine practical strategies with a warm, strengths-based approach, helping clients apply insights from therapy to real-life challenges.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss
Empowering, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 10 insurance carriers
Michelle Gray

Michelle Gray

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“Being able to see my clients find clarity, gain confidence, and feel empowered to change is what keeps joy in my heart.”
Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues, Maternal mental health
Direct, Empowering, Open-minded
Accepts 6 insurance carriers
Kerry Davis

Kerry Davis

Virtual • Indiana


Are you feeling overwhelmed by anxiety, carrying the emotional weight of motherhood, struggling in your relationships, or finding it difficult to navigate a major life transition? Perhaps you're constantly putting everyone else's needs first and have lost sight of yourself in the process. You may feel stuck, exhausted, disconnected, or uncertain about how to move forward.

I specialize in helping adults, parents, and families navigate anxiety, depression, stress, relationship challenges, family conflict, maternal mental health concerns, grief and loss, identity issues, and life transitions. As both a therapist and a mother of teenagers, I understand firsthand the joys and challenges that come with family life and the many roles we hold. I provide a compassionate, supportive space where you can slow down, feel understood, and begin making meaningful changes that align with the life you want to create.

Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss, Identity issues
Inquisitive, Solution-oriented, Warm
Accepts 8 insurance carriers
Jennifer Landis

Jennifer Landis

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My focus is your focus. I am trained in modalities surrounding trauma, motivation, depression/anxiety, etc.... but my preference is to have natural easy conversation that focuses on you.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues
Affirming, Empowering, Solution-oriented
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
Dominique Jackson Pittman

Dominique Jackson Pittman

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“After session, you can expect to continue to reflect on things with an empowerment in knowing you can find peace in it.”
Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues, Identity issues
Affirming, Empowering, Humorous
Accepts 4 insurance carriers
Dr. Pamela McCombs-Matlock

Dr. Pamela McCombs-Matlock

Psychologist

Virtual • Indiana


“My approach is strengths-based, focusing on empowering you to become the best version of yourself while addressing and healing past wounds.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues
Empowering, Humorous, Open-minded
Accepts 3 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Emily Heineke

Emily Heineke

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


I have over 38 years of experience helping children, adults, and families navigate complex emotional and relational challenges. I work from a family-systems and strength-based perspective, focusing on understanding patterns that contribute to ongoing stress and disconnection.

I am direct, thoughtful, and collaborative in my approach. I work with ADHD, anxiety, depression, school concerns, divorce, and family relationship challenges. When working with children, I believe caregiver involvement is essential for meaningful and lasting change.

Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, PTSD
Affirming, Direct, Open-minded
Accepts 6 insurance carriers
Mahogany Brown

Mahogany Brown

Therapist

Virtual • Brownsburg, IN


“I am passionate about creating affirming, inclusive spaces where clients feel supported and understood, and I use practical, real-world approaches tailored to each individual.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Diabetes
Affirming, Inquisitive, Open-minded
Accepts 7 insurance carriers
Madison Knowles

Madison Knowles

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I have had extensive experience with multiple populations including people with special needs, I am Proficient in parent training, family counseling, counseling teens and even adults.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Cultural & ethnic issues
Direct, Energetic, Open-minded
Accepts 4 insurance carriers
Ericka Whitley

Ericka Whitley

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I love using a Strengths-Based approach when working with the clients, as I am a firm believer that everyone has something that makes them unique.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Grief or loss, Relationship issues
Affirming, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 2 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Michelle Prewitt

Michelle Prewitt

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


I’m passionate about supporting clients as they navigate life’s challenges. I believe everyone deserves to have someone by their side through both the highs and the lows.

I take a person-centered approach to therapy, meeting you exactly where you are and creating a space where you feel safe, understood, and supported—especially during vulnerable moments. I show up as my authentic self in sessions so that you can feel comfortable doing the same. My goal is that each time we meet, you leave feeling at least a little lighter—whether that comes from feeling heard, gaining insight, or simply having a space to release what you’ve been carrying.

With over 15 years of experience, I bring both professional knowledge and genuine compassion into my work. I’m known for being kind, approachable, and deeply committed to the therapeutic process.

I’m also a certified yoga instructor and enjoy incorporating mindfulness and grounding techniques into sessions when it feels helpful. I believe in the connection between mind and body and strive to support clients in feeling more balanced, present, and connected to themselves.

It’s truly an honor to walk alongside my clients as they heal, grow, and move forward.

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, Family issues
Affirming, Empowering, Open-minded
Accepts 7 insurance carriers
Shelby Rymers

Shelby Rymers

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I am extremely passionate about helping people gain a deeper understanding about themselves and identify behavioral patterns that no longer benefit them.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues
Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm
Accepts 5 insurance carriers
Patricia Pardy

Patricia Pardy

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


I am a Mental Health Counselor, licensed in NY, MA, NJ, NH, RI, KS, UT, WI, IN, AR, and OR, with over 20 years experience in the counseling field. I have had experience assisting clients with a wide range of concerns, such as, parenting issues, family/personal relationships, grief/loss, depression, anxiety, and anger management.

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues
Humorous, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 10 insurance carriers
L. Colleen McCarthy

L. Colleen McCarthy

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My approach combines science-based methods such as Polyvagal Theory, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, mindfulness, and neuropsychotherapy.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, End of life care, Family issues
Affirming, Empowering, Warm
Accepts 7 insurance carriers
Laura Carpenter

Laura Carpenter

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I'm passionate about supporting individuals through complex life challenges, including family building, depression, anxiety, caregiving, chronic illness, cancer care, grief, parenting, and major life transitions.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions, Depression
Direct, Empowering, Solution-oriented
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
241 - 280 of

About our therapists located within 20 miles of Fishers, IN

Number of therapists within 20 miles of Fishers, IN
There are over 31 therapists in Fishers, IN accepting new patients.
31+
Average years in practice
Watercolor illustration of a bookshelf
10 years
Top specialties offered
Watercolor illustration of specialties
  • 100%Anxiety
  • 97%Depression
  • 84%Stress management
  • 74%Relationship issues
  • 74%Women's issues
Insurances accepted
Watercolor illustration of insurance cards
  • 100%Aetna
  • 90%Cigna
  • 84%Carelon Behavioral Health
  • 71%Ascension
Languages spoken
Watercolor illustration of languages
  • 100%English
  • 3%Korean
  • 3%Mandarin
  • 3%Swahili
  • 3%Yoruba
How they see their clients
Watercolor illustration of therapy session
  • 100%In-person or online
Provider gender
Watercolor illustration of gender identity
  • 77%Woman
  • 23%Man
License types
Watercolor illustration of license
  • 39%Licensed Mental Health Counselor
  • 35%Licensed Clinical Social Worker
  • 16%Licensed Marriage/Family Therapist
  • 10%Advanced Practice Registered Nurse
Treatment approaches
Watercolor illustration of treatment approach
  • 100%Individual therapy
  • 39%Family therapy
  • 35%Couples therapy
  • 23%Child or adolescent therapy

Frequently asked questions

Therapy Chair

Happy patient looking away

Find the right therapist for you

Headway makes it easy to find support for your mental health — from finding the right provider, to understanding costs, to scheduling with ease.

Factors to Consider When Choosing an Anxiety Therapist in Fishers, IN

Searching for therapists in Fishers starts with knowing what kind of support and clinical focus you want. People often look for therapy for anxiety, depression, grief, relationship concerns, life transitions, or work stress. As you compare therapists, look for listed specialties, therapy approaches, and experience that match what you want to work on. A therapist’s bio can help you understand their style, areas of focus, and what sessions may be like.

In a smaller city like Fishers, local appointment options may vary by neighborhood, schedule, and specialty. Virtual therapy can expand your choices while still letting you see a therapist licensed in Indiana. When narrowing your search, consider whether you prefer in-person care near Fishers or virtual sessions, whether the therapist is accepting new clients, and whether their availability fits your schedule. Some therapists also offer a free phone consultation, which can help you decide if the fit feels right before booking.

Therapy in Fishers can be a significant investment without insurance, and using in-network coverage is one of the most reliable ways to reduce session costs. Headway helps you search for therapists who accept insurance, review detailed profiles, check estimated out-of-pocket costs before booking, and choose an appointment time directly. You can browse therapists in Fishers, compare fit, and book when you’re ready.

1 Cost may vary based on your location, age, and insurance coverage.