Skip to main content
Headway

Find an Aetna therapist in Fishers, IN

Book a therapist or psychiatrist in Fishers, IN covered by Aetna

Therapist and patient in a therapy session
Calculator Illustration
Get a cost estimate
People with insurance pay as low as $0 per session through Headway

Top Aetna-covered therapists and psychiatrists in Fishers, IN

Fishers residents with Aetna can connect with mental health providers through Headway, where the average client saves 75% on sessions. Sessions are available both in-person and virtually, with providers specializing in talk therapy and medication management. Many providers have openings soon, making it easy to start your mental health journey.

Dr. Celeste McGill

Dr. Celeste McGill

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“Clients describe me as warm, honest, and deeply supportive. I bring over 30 years of experience working with diverse communities...”
Aetna + 4 others
Anger management, Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, End of life care
Empowering, Solution-oriented, Warm
Estella Ngoie

Estella Ngoie

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


I am passionate about coming alongside you to help reach your goals! I am honored to be a part of each client’s process for healing and change, and value addressing whatever needs and goals are specific to you.

I have been working as a mental health counselor for over ten years, and my favorite part of the job is seeing the resilience and transformation process with each of my clients. I have experience working with individuals of all ages, families, and couples with a variety of concerns including anxiety, addiction, depression, relationship concerns, and trauma.

I am an LMHC that specializes in treating trauma and I'm passionate about working with my clients to find the healing that they have been wanting. I also value being a therapist that is a BIPOC individual, and welcome my clients to bring their cultural concerns and racial trauma to work through in sessions.

Aetna + 3 others
Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, PTSD, Relationship issues
Affirming, Open-minded, Warm

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Brenda Comer

Brenda Comer

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“Therapy sessions are confidential, personalized, and grounded in cognitive-behavioral principles with an eclectic strengths-based perspective.”
Aetna + 4 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression
Empowering, Open-minded, Warm

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Joseph Nemeth

Joseph Nemeth

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Indiana


My name is Joe Nemeth and I am a Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner. I received by doctorate from Rush University in Chicago and have years of experience working with patients who are struggling with their mental health. My practice is focused on medication management of a wide variety of illnesses including anxiety, depression, bipolar disorder, ADHD, PTSD, and more.

Aetna + 4 others
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression
Humorous, Open-minded, Solution-oriented
Samantha Chaplin

Samantha Chaplin

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I often utilize strengths based, skill building approaches to help give you the tools to reach your fullest potential.”
Aetna + 4 others
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Stress management
Energetic, Holistic, Humorous

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Aleah Enyeart

Aleah Enyeart

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My approach to therapy is warm, welcoming, and collaborative while also providing gentle challenges that encourage growth and self-reflection.”
Aetna + 4 others
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Family issues, Grief or loss, Maternal mental health
Challenging, Direct, Empowering
Kerry Davis

Kerry Davis

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


Are you feeling overwhelmed by anxiety, carrying the emotional weight of motherhood, struggling in your relationships, or finding it difficult to navigate a major life transition? Perhaps you're constantly putting everyone else's needs first and have lost sight of yourself in the process. You may feel stuck, exhausted, disconnected, or uncertain about how to move forward.

I specialize in helping adults, parents, and families navigate anxiety, depression, stress, relationship challenges, family conflict, maternal mental health concerns, grief and loss, identity issues, and life transitions. As both a therapist and a mother of teenagers, I understand firsthand the joys and challenges that come with family life and the many roles we hold. I provide a compassionate, supportive space where you can slow down, feel understood, and begin making meaningful changes that align with the life you want to create.

Aetna + 7 others
Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss, Identity issues
Inquisitive, Solution-oriented, Warm
Brandon Kerr

Brandon Kerr

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I provide a supportive, nonjudgmental environment where we work together to identify your strengths, develop practical coping strategies, and achieve your personal goals.”
Accepts Aetna insurance
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, LGBTQIA+
Affirming, Direct, Open-minded

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Rebecca Kleihege

Rebecca Kleihege

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I've been a therapist for over 20 years, working in a variety of settings—from schools and community agencies to private practice.”
Aetna + 7 others
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Family issues
Direct, Empowering, Holistic
Robert Castillo

Robert Castillo

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My role is to gently guide and support you through the stages of change at a pace that feels right for you.”
Aetna + 4 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions
Direct, Empowering, Solution-oriented
Carolyn Logue

Carolyn Logue

Therapist

Virtual • Warsaw, IN


“With a trauma-informed approach, my focus will be on who you are as an individual, where you are within your current environment, and what you would like your trajectory to be for your future.”
Aetna + 10 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions
Affirming, Solution-oriented, Warm
Jennifer Fitzwater

Jennifer Fitzwater

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I prioritize trauma-informed and culturally sensitive care, ensuring a client-centered, relational approach where you can explore and manage complex feelings safely.”
Aetna + 4 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression
Direct, Humorous, Open-minded
Kimberly Deus Sullivan

Kimberly Deus Sullivan

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“It has always been my goal to provide a safe space that helps my clients to learn about them, learn new shills to help them work on their.”
Aetna + 8 others
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, Eating disorders
Challenging, Humorous, Warm
Maria Wilson

Maria Wilson

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My style is direct, humorous, and goal oriented. I am non-judgmental and caring. My goal is for every client to feel heard and to have a partner to work through difficult situations in life.”
Aetna + 9 others
Anger management, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Diabetes
Affirming, Direct, Solution-oriented
Dr. Valerie Markley

Dr. Valerie Markley

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Indiana


“I believe in client-centered care, working collaboratively with clients to help them achieve their best potential.”
Aetna + 7 others
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, End of life care
Affirming, Participatory, Warm
Lauren Peterson

Lauren Peterson

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • Lowell, IN


“I meet clients where they are at and start to assist them with the journey, they want to partake in.”
Aetna + 3 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression
Empowering, Open-minded, Solution-oriented

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Audrey Elam

Audrey Elam

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I believe in each person's capacity for growth and transformation, and I feel honored to walk alongside my clients as they navigate meaningful change using evidence-based practices.”
Aetna + 6 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, PTSD
Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm
Diane Conover

Diane Conover

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“Being honest, transparent, supportive and challenging is the atmosphere we will set in our times together.”
Aetna + 5 others
Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss
Challenging, Empowering, Solution-oriented

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Janise Winston

Janise Winston

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I've been practicing for more than a decade with extensive experience in trauma, grief, depression and anxiety.”
Aetna + 14 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Cultural & ethnic issues
Empowering, Open-minded, Solution-oriented
Amanda Routten

Amanda Routten

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I believe that you are the expert on your own life, and my role is to provide the tools and perspective needed to help you heal and grow.”
Aetna + 6 others
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, Grief or loss
Empowering, Open-minded, Solution-oriented

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Zachary Kyle

Zachary Kyle

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


Hello! My name is Zachary! I am happy you visited my profile. Before you begin browsing, I just want to say you are strong and you have incredible power in you to journey towards healing. I believe in your success and your potential.

I received my Bachelor of Arts at Goshen College and my Master of Social Work at Andrews University. I am a LCSW in Indiana, LISW in Ohio, and a LSCSW in Kansas.

I have experience in care management and facilitation, providing counseling to juveniles on probation, delivering therapy to those who have been court ordered, doing home-based clinical services, implementing and administering Family Centered Treatment© to families, hospice social work, community mental health, certified clinical behavioral health clinics, conducting counseling to geriatric and SPMI populations, as well as telehealth.

Aetna + 4 others
Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions, Cultural & ethnic issues
Challenging, Inquisitive, Warm
Hollie Shigley

Hollie Shigley

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I believe that healing isn't about becoming someone new, it's about reconnecting with who you are underneath the stress, expectations, and challenges you've been carrying.”
Aetna + 6 others
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Maternal mental health
Creative, Inquisitive, Solution-oriented
Saleha Khan

Saleha Khan

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


Hi! I’m a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) and Licensed Alcohol and Drug Counselor (LCADC). I specialize in supporting individuals dealing with addiction, mental health concerns, and life transitions. I work with adults struggling with anxiety, depression, substance use, trauma, and relationship challenges. I use evidence-based therapies like CBT, Motivational Interviewing (MI), and trauma-informed care, always tailored to your unique needs.

I’m here to help you feel supported and empowered as you work toward a healthier, more balanced life.

Aetna + 12 others
Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues, Relationship issues
Empowering, Solution-oriented, Warm
Ana Newman

Ana Newman

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I am warm, supportive, non-judgmental and goal-oriented. But as we get to know each other, you will see that I don't just smile and nod while you talk, I will call you out on your stuff and challenge you so that you can grow, learn and not need me...”
Aetna + 8 others
Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, PTSD, Relationship issues
Empowering, Solution-oriented, Warm

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Kimberly Salsman

Kimberly Salsman

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“With empowering and solution focused therapy, I strive to assist you to build skills, release stressors and/or trauma, and live the life you want.”
Aetna + 16 others
Bipolar disorder, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss, Maternal mental health
Empowering, Open-minded, Solution-oriented
Margaret Lipman

Margaret Lipman

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My therapy approach is collaborative, supportive, and direct, focusing on helping you reconnect with your truth, joy, and life fulfillment.”
Aetna + 5 others
Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Identity issues, OCD
Inquisitive, Open-minded, Warm
Michelle Alexander

Michelle Alexander

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • Michigan City, IN


“From beginning diagnostics and thorough evaluation to weaving applicable treatment methods, (M-CBT, DBT, emotional resilience training)...”
Aetna + 1 others
Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Grief or loss, PTSD
Affirming, Empowering, Warm

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Christina Stanco

Christina Stanco

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“Her passion is teaching clients skills that empower them to be the best version of themselves while providing a safe space to explore their concerns.”
Aetna + 4 others
Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Diabetes, Family issues
Empowering, Humorous, Warm
Jennie Wentz

Jennie Wentz

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I'm skilled at meeting people where they're at emotionally and providing a comfortable and social atmosphere to explore issues.”
Aetna + 12 others
Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss
Empowering, Open-minded, Warm
Ginger Mote

Ginger Mote

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I like to keep things real, practical, and honest. We'll talk, reflect, and sometimes get creative to uncover what is happening beneath the surface.”
Aetna + 8 others
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Family issues
Creative, Empowering, Humorous

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Diann Binns

Diann Binns

Therapist

Virtual • Crown Point, IN


“I am genuine and warm in my approach, understanding that the deeper work can only happen once trust is built.”
Aetna + 11 others
Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, End of life care, Family issues
Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm
Spencer Lee

Spencer Lee

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I believe in meeting my clients where they are and helping them achieve the goals they set for themselves.”
Aetna + 16 others
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression
Direct, Open-minded, Solution-oriented
Kristina Devors

Kristina Devors

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“Krissy's main goal at the end of each session is for her clients to feel encouraged and more recharged than when they walked in.”
Aetna + 9 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions
Creative, Empowering, Open-minded
Cheri Littlefield

Cheri Littlefield

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My approach is grounded in compassion and empowerment. I want to help you find your voice, build a sense of safety within yourself, and advocate for the life you want.”
Aetna + 4 others
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Grief or loss, PTSD
Affirming, Holistic, Participatory

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Dr. Stacey Arnold

Dr. Stacey Arnold

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“My approach to therapy is strengths based. I believe in initially taking time to get to know my clients well and determining what strengths they have.”
Aetna + 13 others
Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues
Affirming, Empowering, Solution-oriented
Jodi Herche

Jodi Herche

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Indiana


“I believe mental health care should feel safe, collaborative, and free of judgement, where people are seen as whole humans - not a labeled diagnosis.”
Aetna + 5 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions
Empowering, Holistic, Open-minded
Jennifer Weir-Harden

Jennifer Weir-Harden

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


“I do not have a cookie cutter approach to therapy. I use a trauma-informed, relational approach grounded in psychodynamic and attachment-based therapy.”
Accepts Aetna insurance
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss
Holistic, Open-minded, Warm
Kelli Hoeflinger

Kelli Hoeflinger

Therapist

Virtual • Indiana


I’ve spent the last twenty years working with adolescents, young adults, and their families, and in recent years I’ve expanded my practice to include adults of all ages. My greatest strength as a therapist is my ability to build genuine rapport and trust, creating a space where clients feel understood, supported, and safe to be themselves.

I hold a master’s degree in counseling and have additional training and experience in grief, anxiety, stress, trauma, life transitions, academic counseling, post-secondary planning, and career counseling. Whether you’re navigating a major change, processing something difficult, or simply feeling stuck, my goal is to walk alongside you with warmth, practical tools, and evidence-based support.

Aetna + 14 others
Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss, Identity issues
Empowering, Solution-oriented, Warm
Nikki Rogers

Nikki Rogers

Therapist

Virtual • Indianapolis, IN


“I am passionate about helping individuals and families feel heard, supported, and understood. My 20 plus years of professional background includes working closely with children, adults, and families in both home and community-based settings, addressing concerns such as behavioral challenges, family conflict, trauma, and life stressors.

I have a special interest in supporting families, strengthening relationships, and helping clients navigate difficult transitions with confidence and clarity.”

Aetna + 5 others
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions
Direct, Empowering, Warm
Dr. Michael Whiteside

Dr. Michael Whiteside

Therapist

Virtual • Bloomington, IN


“I am a compassionate, communal, and comedic Licensed Clinical Social Worker dedicated to helping others regain control of their life and living life to the fullest.”
Aetna + 4 others
Anger management, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues
Affirming, Empowering, Warm

What type of therapy does Aetna cover?

Aetna plans can vary, but many cover a range of therapy types. Below are some common options that may be included in your coverage.
watercolor illustration of a coffee table with tea

Frequently asked questions

Therapy Chair

Happy patient looking away

Affordable care that fits you — and your Aetna plan

Headway makes it easy to get affordable in-network mental health care with Aetna — from finding the right therapist or psychiatrist, to understanding costs, to booking your first session.

Find a provider - your way

Use left and right arrow keys to switch tabs. Press Shift+Tab to return to the tab list from links in the selected tab.

1 Cost may vary based on your location, age, and insurance coverage.